Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
I believe he is saying that you don't run the movie from beginning to end and capture the role names that are missing from the credits as the movie is playing, all the way through.

That is what Rifter claims he does.

I never claimed any such thing.  Why must you ALWAYS twist what somebody says?  You are rapidly becoming not worth the effort to even try to discuss anything with.

Quoting Rifter:

Quote:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Are you seriously suggesting that people should should watch every movie from beginning to end in order to do the cast list? 

No matter what anyone says, I do not believe anyone is doing this!

I do it.  Regularly.  I'd also be careful about suggesting I'm not telling the truth.

Then why did you say "I do it.  Regularly." 

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
I believe he is saying that you don't run the movie from beginning to end and capture the role names that are missing from the credits as the movie is playing, all the way through.

That is what Rifter claims he does.

I never claimed any such thing.  Why must you ALWAYS twist what somebody says?  You are rapidly becoming not worth the effort to even try to discuss anything with.

Quoting Rifter:

Quote:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Are you seriously suggesting that people should should watch every movie from beginning to end in order to do the cast list? 

No matter what anyone says, I do not believe anyone is doing this!

I do it.  Regularly.  I'd also be careful about suggesting I'm not telling the truth.

Then why did you say "I do it.  Regularly." 

Do you have a problem reading English?  You claimed you don't believe anyone watches a movie to get cast names, and I said I do it regularly.  Then you turn right around and call me a liar.  WHAT THE HELL IS YOUR PROBLEM, BOY????  Maybe you should try proofreading what you write before shooting off your big mouth.

Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
I believe he is saying that you don't run the movie from beginning to end and capture the role names that are missing from the credits as the movie is playing, all the way through.

That is what Rifter claims he does.

I never claimed any such thing.  Why must you ALWAYS twist what somebody says?  You are rapidly becoming not worth the effort to even try to discuss anything with.

Quoting Rifter:

Quote:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Are you seriously suggesting that people should should watch every movie from beginning to end in order to do the cast list? 

No matter what anyone says, I do not believe anyone is doing this!

I do it.  Regularly.  I'd also be careful about suggesting I'm not telling the truth.

Then why did you say "I do it.  Regularly." 

Do you have a problem reading English?  You claimed you don't believe anyone watches a movie to get cast names, and I said I do it regularly.  Then you turn right around and call me a liar.  WHAT THE HELL IS YOUR PROBLEM, BOY????  Maybe you should try proofreading what you write before shooting off your big mouth.

Perhaps if I bold the pertinent sentence for you, you will be able to read and comprehend what it is that you said you do regularly. 



Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Are you seriously suggesting that people should should watch every movie from beginning to end in order to do the cast list? 

No matter what anyone says, I do not believe anyone is doing this!

I do it.  Regularly.  I'd also be careful about suggesting I'm not telling the truth.

Then why did you say "I do it.  Regularly." 

Yeah I think this topic as run its course, the first poster was talking about more complete role names.  We have already decieded that if the roles are listed in the credits then take it from there.

The second topic was if no role was listed, someone suggested that we keep the role names the same across all seasons of a series.  I see no issue with that as long as the contributor is aware of the other contributions.  I don't think the comuninity as a whole would disagree.

The other was where to get the roles, the rules say we can use another source to help determine the role.  Another source can be the DVD packaging, menus, subtitles or how other actors address a particular character.  I don't think agrueing over how some members determine the name does anyone any good.

I've used the following;
Fan Sites
Close Captions or Subtitles
DVD packaging
DVD menus (cast bios)
When a character address' another character
Tombstones when a character is dead

And if I can't figure out the role name I leave it blank in hopes that another contributor will have better luck than me.  The nice thing about having a community built database.

EPKJ:

I don't feel at all uncomfortable. You are an insulting and abusive user, we have had any number of users such as yourself and the outcome is always the same . So just keep up your behavior and eventually...you won't be here.

You were probably one of those that back in the old days used to say we don't have to pay any attention because they are Guidelines and Guidelines don't HAVE to be followed. So they became Rules that do have to be followed, there are places you can go that do not have the functionality of profiler but also don't have the Rules to be followed, in short you can do whatever you wish.

Skip

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting EPKJ:

Quote:


By the way, it is nice to know that Skipnet does in fact give Rifter his marching orders.

This does confirm something that we all already knew, doesn't it?

Quoting skipnet50

Quote:
I have already requested Rifter to disengage.

Both of you guys can go bugger yourselves.

                   


Skip

Once again I call on ken to lock this thread sadness, I agree with Joe.
The personal attacks are uncalled for and unnecessary.

Skip