| Contribution Discussion |  | | MGM Vintage Classics (?)
Quoting zappman: Quote:
To me, it is neither "Vintage Classics" nor "MGM Vintage Classics". There is the "Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer logo" on the cover. There are the words "Vintage Classics" or the cover, but neither of those is an edition. "Vintage Classics" is just some text they put on the cover (not an actual edition).
I checked several MGM DVDs in my collection with similar covers and nowhere on the actual DVD disc label does it say "Vintage Classics".
I actually have a couple of doubled dipped DVDs, and the cover on one copy says "Vintage Classics" and the cover on other DVD cover does not, but both have the exact same DVD with the exact same label inside.
If the cover actually said "Vintage Classics Edition" or "MGM Vintage Classics Edition", I would accept that in the profile.
If the cover actually said "Vintage Classics Collection" or "MGM Vintage Classics Collection", I would accept that in the profile. I agree with this. The rules state that "the Edition field is for distinguishing between DVDs, and for indicating special versions and collections"; Vintage Classics is neither a special version nor a collection. |
Nosferatu |
| DVD Profiler Online | | | What DVDs have you bought this week? (1 2 3 ...453 )
Charmed: The Complete Fourth Season All Regions Released: 2/28/2006 Full Frame 1.33 Charmed: The Complete Sixth Season Region 1 Released: 10/17/2006 Full Frame 1.33 Charmed: The Complete Fifth Season Region 1 Released: 6/6/2006 Full Frame 1.33 Charmed: The Complete Seventh Season Region 1 Released: 2/6/2007 Full Frame 1.33 Charmed: The Final Season Region 1 Released: 9/11/2007 Full Frame 1.33 The Big Bang Theory: The Complete Fifth Season Regions 1, 3, 4 Released: 9/11/2012 Anamorphic 1.78 Lawman: The Complete Second Season All Regions Released: 8/25/2015 Full Frame 1.37 |
drvrjon |
| DVD Profiler Online | | | What 4K Ultra HDs s have you bought this week? (1 2 3 ...20 )
Arrived last yesterday from Dead End DVD. Blood on Satan's Claw: Tigon Collection All Regions Released: 25/03/2024 Widescreen 1.85:1 Witchfinder General: Tigon Collection All Regions Released: 25/03/2024 Widescreen 1.85:1 The Conan Chronicles: Limited Edition: Arrow Video All Regions Released: 30/01/2024 Widescreen [DIVLEFT MARGIN="10px"][/DIVLEFT] |
Rutan |
| DVD Profiler Online | | | What Blu-rays have you Bought this Week (1 2 3 ...342 )
Arrived last 48hrs. Ladies Who Do All Regions Released: 14/11/2022 Widescreen 1.66:1 The Female Executioner: Limited Slipcover Edition All Regions Released: 30/08/2022 Widescreen 1.66:1 Jess Franco's Mansion of the Living Dead All Regions Released: 4/06/2022 Anamorphic 2.35:1 Violent Streets: The Umberto Lenzi/Tomas Milian Collection All Regions Released: 28/03/2023 Widescreen 2.35:1 The Shootist: Limited Edition All Regions Released: 12/03/2024 Widescreen 1.85:1 |
Rutan |