|
|
Welcome to the Invelos forums. Please read the forum
rules before posting.
Read access to our public forums is open to everyone. To post messages, a free
registration is required.
If you have an Invelos account, sign in to post.
|
|
|
|
Invelos Forums->DVD Profiler: Contribution Discussion |
Page:
1 2 Previous Next
|
"Isolated Score" in the "Other Features" field |
|
|
|
Author |
Message |
| T!M | Profiling since Dec. 2000 |
Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 8,736 |
| Posted: | | | | For many years now, I have consistently seen "Isolated Score" or "Music Only Track" being listed in the "Other Features" field. Now, a contribution adding an "Isolated Score", listed on the back cover under the header "Special Features", to the "Other Features" field, was voted down by one user, noting that it's not needed as it's already listed as an audio track, so I wanted to see how the community felt about this.
The reasoning behind listing this in the "Other Features" field is, to me, the fact that it *is* in fact a bonus feature. Again, it's listed on the back cover under the header "Special Features", so when I look at the "Features" section in DVD Profiler, that's where I would expect to find it.
As far as the argument "it's already listed as an audio track" - that doesn't apply to similar features either. For instance: an audio commentary is also listed as an audio track, but that doesn't stop it from being listed under "Features" as well. A trivia track may be listed in the "Subtitles" section, but that doesn't stop it from being listed under "Features" as well. Why would this be any different? | | | Last edited: by T!M |
| Registered: October 4, 2008 | Reputation: | Posts: 330 |
| Posted: | | | | Since, I was the no vote, let me state my opinion on the reasoning behind it.
The other examples given (commentary, trivia track) have respective checkboxes to be used, so they are not Other Features, which is the topic at hand. The rules say to use Other Features for extras that don't have a specific indicator. This does, the Music Only selection in Audio. The rules also say if you're unsure if an Extra should be listed, it probably shouldn't be.
I see no reason to put something into Other Features that is listed elsewhere, and the definition in the rules doesn't seem to support adding it in my view. |
| Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 17,334 |
| Posted: | | | | have to agree with primetime21! | | | Pete |
| | T!M | Profiling since Dec. 2000 |
Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 8,736 |
| Posted: | | | | I *really* don't get this stance. Again: a commentary audio track is listed both as a feature and as an audio track - why wouldn't the same apply to an isolated score track? Whether it's a checkbox or not should not matter - if it does, we use the checkbox, if it doesn't, it goes into "Other Features". The point is not where to list it in the features section - it's whether we consider it part of the disc's special features at all. If we *do* consider it part of the disc's special features, then surely it belongs in DVD Profiler's features section. If we don't, then it doesn't. But the back cover of the disc certainly does make this out to be part of the features, as it's listed there under a big "Special Features" header. So if the cover list it as a feature, why wouldn't we do the same? Why would we *not* want to see this included when looking at DVD Profiler's "Features" tab?
Again, if I look at the DVD Profiler's "Features" tab for any profile, then I expect that to show me a full list of features present on that particular disc - some in the form of checkboxes, others in the form of the "Other Features" field. Other features that are already listed elsewhere - audio commentary, trivia tracks - are still always included in the features section. So why would this particular special feature be the single exception somehow? I honestly don't get that. If it *is* part of the disc's features, I expect to see it in DVD Profiler's features section. | | | Last edited: by T!M |
| Registered: October 22, 2015 | Reputation: | Posts: 274 |
| Posted: | | | | I understand T!M's reasoning, however, I have always followed the path outlined by primetime21 because I regard the "Isolated Track" as not an add-on feature, rather, it is already an integral part of the film itself. The Audio tracks section covers this with the "Music Only" option.
Audio tracks and subtitles are an integral component of the film and are not considered to be add-on special features.
However, "Commentary" has an Audio option in the profile as well as a check box in the Features section. I believe this is because it is an add-on component, not integral to the film, just like all the other check boxes in the Features section. Removal of any special features has no impact on the film.
"Other Features" is any add-on special feature not covered by the existing check boxes in the Features section.
Hope that provides some clarity on the topic. |
| Registered: March 14, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 4,667 |
| Posted: | | | | Adding Music Only Track under Other Features is redundant.
Of course, so is the Commentary checkbox when we have Commentary as Audio Track. I don't know the thinking behind that, but I have a guess. Perhaps the checkbox was there before we got the possibility of adding Commentary under Audio? If so, then it makes sense that Ken did not remove the checkbox since that would mean losing info in older profiles. But that's just speculation on my part.
Anyway, I don't see any need to add redundant info in Other Features. | | | My freeware tools for DVD Profiler users. Gunnar |
| | T!M | Profiling since Dec. 2000 |
Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 8,736 |
| Posted: | | | | To me, it still boils down to this: if the back cover lists it as a special feature, I expect to see it on DVD Profiler's "Features" tab.
Literally *every* conceivable feature found on the disc, or even physically accompanying the disc, gets listed in one form or another in DVD Profiler's "Features" section. Why would there be one single exception? | | | Last edited: by T!M |
| Registered: March 14, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 4,667 |
| Posted: | | | | Quoting T!M: Quote: To me, it still boils down to: if the back cover lists it as a special feature, I expect to see it on DVD Profiler's "Features" tab. Seriously, Tim? You'd list Anamorphic Widescreen, Languages, Subtitles and Interactive Menu under Other Features? | | | My freeware tools for DVD Profiler users. Gunnar |
| | T!M | Profiling since Dec. 2000 |
Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 8,736 |
| Posted: | | | | Of course not - but I should have expected someone to dig up a cover like that... But I do consider the presence of an "Isolated Score" as a special feature, and therefore I expect to see it on DVD Profiler's "Features" tab. Another example, then: Each of those special features is represented in DVD Profiler's "Features" section - except one. Why would there be one exception? | | | Last edited: by T!M |
| Registered: March 14, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 4,667 |
| Posted: | | | | It's a lone exception only in that example. But I can did up hundreds of old DVDs that have silly thing listed as features. So what makes Isolated Score so different? | | | My freeware tools for DVD Profiler users. Gunnar |
| | T!M | Profiling since Dec. 2000 |
Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 8,736 |
| Posted: | | | | Unlike things as the film's aspect ratio, or which subtitles are included, which I'm sure neither you or me, nor any other user here, would qualify as "bonus material", I *do* consider an isolated score to be an actual special feature. Again, I've showed you a back cover - and I can show you many more, just a few examples below - where the back cover explicitly names an isolated score as part of the disc's special features. And each of those special features deserve to be represented in DVD Profiler's "Features" section. The contribution rules certainly don't make an exception to leave this out. And other features that are listed in other sections (audio commentaries, trivia tracks), are still always also included in DVD Profiler's features section. I honestly don't see why this single specific feature would be the sole exception. The only valid reason to ban it from the features section would be to say: "it's not a special feature", but not only do I beg to differ, but the covers do that as well. If the covers consistently lists this as a special feature, then why wouldn't we do the same? The bottom line remains that if you agree that it's a part of the disc's special features, then it should be listed in DVD Profiler's features section. There's really no more to it than that. There really isn't anything else that we truly consider to be part of the special features, but which isn't listed in the features section. Even features that are already profiled elsewhere, like audio commentaries or trivia tracks, must, per the rules, always be included in the features section as well. And there is absolutely no exception in the rules that would lead us to treat a trivia subtitle track any different than an isolated score track. There's nothing left to add, so I'm pretty much done with this topic. My approach will remain what it always was: the features section in my database will always try to reflect all of the disc's bonus materials, which means that it will include a mention of an isolated score whenever one is present. | | | Last edited: by T!M |
| Registered: March 14, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 4,667 |
| Posted: | | | | I just didn't buy your blanket statement that if it is listed as a special feature it should be included in the Features tab. It seems to me that you want it included just out of principle, even if it doesn't actually add any useful information.
Personally I wouldn't add it, but I wouldn't remove it either if it's already there. | | | My freeware tools for DVD Profiler users. Gunnar |
| Registered: October 4, 2008 | Reputation: | Posts: 330 |
| Posted: | | | | Quote: Even features that are already profiled elsewhere, like audio commentaries or trivia tracks, must, per the rules, always be included in the features section as well. I don't see where it says that in the rules. I do see where it says "Use the Other free text box for Extras that do not have a specific indicator." and as previously mentioned, this does. There are so many DVD, Blu-rays, etc. that pulling up what one says is a special feature versus another is fruitless. One of your examples you posted says High Definition Transfer, which was a common one when Blu-rays first came out. So should that be an Other Feature? It also states "If you're unsure whether a particular Extra should be listed here, it probably shouldn't be." You seem sure that it should be, so you can put it there locally. But in general people seem unsure, so for the official profile that seems to indicate it shouldn't be. |
| Registered: March 13, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 3,197 |
| Posted: | | | | If Ken had wanted Isolated Score listed twice he could have added a check box for it like he did for Commentary. He didn't, which at least tells me that it's not required information. Personally I wouldn't add it to the Other features field for the simple reason that it can not be "Other" if it's already covered elsewhere. A feature yes, but not an Other feature. But would I care to remove it if it's already added? Probably not. | | | First registered: February 15, 2002 |
| Registered: May 2, 2009 | Reputation: | Posts: 490 |
| Posted: | | | | This isn't really a big issue for me, even if I think this type of extra is rather exclusive and coveted (I remember Alien having it on an early (the first, actually!) DVD release and it was just awesome to have Jerry Goldsmith's music for the beginning of the movie, and all.) To me, it's enough to have the option "Music Only" among the audio tracks and that is also convenient to filter, while you can't filter free text, from e.g. Other Features. One thing that has bothered me since we got the possibility to choose "Commentary" for the Audio field, is that you can't set in what language the commentary is. For example there exist English speaking movies but which can have e.g. French commentary and which may even not be subtitled (since the vast majority of French releases are non-English friendly). | | | Last edited: by MikaLove |
| Registered: March 14, 2007 | Reputation: | Posts: 4,667 |
| Posted: | | | | Some statistics for what it's worth: Out of 8177 profiles in my collection, 196 had Music Only set in Audio Tracks. Out of those, only 14 also had it listed in Other Features. 15 profiles had it listed in Other Features, but not in Audio Tracks. You can make what you want out of that ... | | | My freeware tools for DVD Profiler users. Gunnar |
|
|
Invelos Forums->DVD Profiler: Contribution Discussion |
Page:
1 2 Previous Next
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|