Invelos Forums: Contribution comments for [4010884259940.5]

This forum contains notes submitted with contributions for this profile. Please consider the comments made by other users when contributing updates to this profile.

This forum is view-only; new notes are posted as contributions are received.

Read access to our public forums is open to everyone. To post messages, a free registration is required.

If you have an Invelos account, sign in to post.

Page: 1 2

Previous Next

Contribution comments for [4010884259940.5] (Locked)

Author

Message

	MTdynaMiTe

Registered: January 27, 2010

Posts: 6

Posted:

- edition added as seen on cover (see spine of the case)
- disc description changed according to rules
- cast and crew corrected/completed exactly as credited

Evaluate this contribution

*Updated Notes*
- edition added as seen on cover (see spine of the case, compare to this http://file1.npage.de/004736/86/bilder/thor.jpg)
- disc description changed according to rules
- cast and crew corrected/completed exactly as credited
*Updated Notes*
- edition added as seen on cover (see spine of the case, compare to this http://file1.npage.de/004736/86/bilder/thor.jpg)
- disc description changed according to rules
- cast and crew corrected/completed exactly as credited

@Looper2: "There's always a note if there are 2 discs" is not correct. I own some converse examples. However, it's correct that only a note "2 DVDs" or "2 BDs" etc. wouldn't be an "edition". But the term "set" or "collection" etc. brings it home.
*Updated Notes*
- edition added as seen on cover (see spine of the case, compare to this http://file1.npage.de/004736/86/bilder/thor.jpg)
- disc description changed according to rules
- cast and crew corrected/completed exactly as credited

@Looper2: "There's always a note if there are 2 discs" is not correct. I own some converse examples. However, it's correct that only a note "2 DVDs" or "2 BDs" etc. wouldn't be an "edition". But the term "set" or "collection" etc. brings it home.
@other no-voters: see picture link above

Profile Contribution Approved Aug 25 2012 8:59AM

Last edited: by MTdynaMiTe

	MTdynaMiTe

Registered: January 27, 2010

Posts: 6

Posted:

Gerrit Schmidt-Foß [Gerrit Schmidt-Foss] --> checked with credit lookup

Evaluate this contribution

Profile Contribution Approved Mar 28 2013 5:54PM

	TomGaines
	Registered Sept. 24, 2001

Registered: March 13, 2007

Reputation: High Rating

Posts: 2,005

Posted:

removed unnecessary group divider "Englische Darsteller". It is against the rules:

Quote:
"Cast", "In order of appearance" or other similar headers at the start of the credits should not be entered.

Evaluate this contribution

Profile Contribution Approved Apr 12 2013 6:49PM

	bbbbb
	on steroids

Registered: March 14, 2007

Posts: 5,734

Posted:

Cast: marked the Stimmen as Voices.

Evaluate this contribution

Profile Contribution Approved Apr 19 2013 6:38PM

Don't confuse while the film is playing with when the film is played. [Ken Cole, DVD Profiler Architect]

	bbbbb
	on steroids

Registered: March 14, 2007

Posts: 5,734

Posted:

Cast: If we have the German Voices we should also have the French Voices. Just like the German voices they aren't credited in the movie at all. Both are on a separate short video file which is started after the movie has ended.
Depending on the language selection (english: movie just ends): german: 01012.m2ts, french: 00101.m2ts

Evaluate this contribution

Profile Contribution Declined Apr 27 2013 4:55PM

Don't confuse while the film is playing with when the film is played. [Ken Cole, DVD Profiler Architect]

	bbbbb
	on steroids

Registered: March 14, 2007

Posts: 5,734

Posted:

Cast: marked the Stimmen as Uncredited, they are not credited in the movie at all. Instead, they are mentioned in a separate, short video file (01012.m2ts), which is started after the movie has already ended. If you have selected the german audio option.
Also removed the dividers. There are no such dividers, neither in the movie nor in the additional video file. We do not invent dividers and their captions.

Evaluate this contribution

*Updated Notes*
Cast: marked the Stimmen as Uncredited, they are not credited in the movie at all. Instead, they are mentioned in a separate, short video file (01012.m2ts), which is started after the movie has already ended. If you have selected the german audio option.
Also removed the dividers. There are no such dividers, neither in the movie nor in the additional video file. We do not invent dividers and their captions.

No-Vote from TomGaines: "from rules: Do not include artificial actor entries to act as separators between cast lists. (e.g. "--JAPANESE CAST--"), instead use the Divider feature for this."
But I did not include any actor entry at all. Instead, I removed the non-existent dividers. The Divider feature from The Rules is not a carte blanche to invent non-existent dividers and captions. The Divider feature is the means to illustrate credited cast divisions.

Profile Contribution Declined May 4 2013 3:57PM

Don't confuse while the film is playing with when the film is played. [Ken Cole, DVD Profiler Architect]

Last edited: by bbbbb

	_ppj_
	Meemaw

Registered: May 18, 2007

Reputation: High Rating

Posts: 876

Posted:

corrected Crew-divider as credited and according to the rules,
except the divider for "Luma Pictures";

delete Shane Mahan Lindsay McGowan as "Creature Design"
and please re-audit me ixäctly, but both are credited as 'Frost Giant Prosthetics and Suit Effects by LEGACA EFFECTS - "Suit Construction Supervisors", and even for me is this not a "Creature Design"

Evaluate this contribution

Profile Contribution Approved 2016-02-19 13:12:16