Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title with a capital "I".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
Evaluate this contribution
*Updated Notes*
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title with a capital "I".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
Update: There have been several "No" votes so far that say the capitalization on the cover should be followed. As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "the big hit" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious that these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with wider, established rules of grammar."
Interestingly, anyone who argues that "i, Robot" is correct is not even following a strict interpretation of the rule, which would dictate that "i, ROBOT" is correct. I conclude from this that are really only two valid possibilitie
*Updated Notes*
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title with a capital "I".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
Update: There have been several "No" votes that put forth the opinion that the capitalization on the cover should be followed. As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "the big hit" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious that these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with wider, more established rules of grammar."
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which would dictate that "i, ROBOT" is correct. I conclude from this that are really onl
*Updated Notes*
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title with a capital "I".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
There have been several "No" votes that put forth the opinion that the capitalization on the cover should be followed. As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "the big hit" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with established rules of grammar."
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which would dictate that "i, ROBOT" is correct.
*Updated Notes*
Forum thread:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=265945
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title with a capital "I".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
There have been several "No" votes that put forth the opinion that the capitalization on the cover should be followed. As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "the big hit" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with established rules of grammar."
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which would dictate that "i, R
*Updated Notes*
Forum thread:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=265945
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title as "I, Robot".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "planet earth" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with established rules of grammar"; rather, it means to check capitalization *with regard to* established rules.
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which would dictate that "i, ROBOT" is correct.
*Updated Notes*
Forum thread:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=265945
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title as "I, Robot".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
There is some debate over "i, Robot" vs. "I, Robot". As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "planet earth" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with established rules of grammar"; rather, it means to check capitalization WITH REGARD TO those established rules.
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which would dictate
*Updated Notes*
Forum thread:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=265945
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. The Fox online store lists this title as "I, Robot".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
There is some debate over "i, Robot" vs. "I, Robot". As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "planet earth" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as printed even if it conflicts with established rules of grammar"; rather, it means to check capitalization WITH REGARD TO those established rules.
Interestingly, anyone who advocates "i, Robot" is not even following a strict interpretation of the Invelos rule, which says "i, ROBO
*Updated Notes*
Forum thread:
http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=265945
Capitalized title. The lower-case "i" on the cover is stylized. Fox online lists the title as "I, Robot".
http://www.foxstore.com/detail.php?item=5283
There is some debate over "i, Robot" vs. "I, Robot". As a counterexample, consider covers where the titles are printed entirely in lower case - e.g, "planet earth" and "good night, and good luck." It's obvious these are stylized and that they should be listed in the database following the rules of English capitalization. From these examples, it's clear that the Invelos rule "Check capitalization of the title" is not intended to mean "Always follow the capitalization as